Skip to Main Content

Print | Bookmark | Font Size: + |

Formal Telephone Discussion Demonstration Updates from C2C

In 2015 CMS authorized the Formal Telephone Discussion Demonstration. C2C mailed out the first scheduling letter in January 2016 and the first discussion was held in February of 2016. At that time, the demo was limited to oxygen and glucose diabetic testing supplies only, and it was only in jurisdiction C and D.  As of October 31, 2016, the demo has now been expanded to all DME appeal types with the exception to claims or suppliers that are already subject to another CMS initiative.  For example, the settlement conference facilitation, or serial claims initiative, or prior authorization for power mobility devices, the demonstration is still only in Jurisdiction C and D.

The purpose of the Formal Telephone Discussion Demonstration is to conduct formal recorded discussions with suppliers prior to C2C's reconsideration decision. Participation in the demonstration gives selected suppliers the opportunity to discuss their appeal or case with the decision maker. The supplier has the opportunity to provide verbal testimony, and provide additional documentation that could assist in reaching a favorable determination.

As a result of the demonstration the expected outcome is improved proper claim submission to the DME MAC from suppliers who are participating in the phone discussion demonstration.

There is also a reopening component of the demonstration that allows potential cases to be remanded back to the QIC from the ALJ level.

Benefits to participating in the Formal telephone discussion are as follows:

  • The supplier gets to provide any verbal testimony during the call
  • The supplier has 14 days after the call is held to provide any missing or critical documentation that is needed to support a favorable decision
  • During the Phone discussion, the supplier will receive feedback and education on CMS policies and requirements.

Benefits to participating in the Reopening process are as follows:

  • Supplier will receive claim payment sooner than at the ALJ
  • Ability to submit documents on cases pending at the ALJ
  • Telephone Discussion on reopening case as necessary

The Formal Telephone Discussion Demonstration process is as follows:

First C2C, the Qualified Independent Contractor or QIC, receives the initial appeal request. Then the QIC determines if the appeal meets the criteria for a telephone discussion (Jurisdiction C or D) and it is not in any other CMS initiative.

Next C2C notifies the supplier of the scheduled discussion date by a mailed notification letter which includes a contact information form to be faxed back to C2C indicating election to participate. If C2C does not receive the contact information sheet within 14 days of the date of the letter, they will assume you do not wish to participate and the appeal will be handled through the standard reconsideration process.

The notification letter looks like all other C2C correspondence, the subject line will state Formal Telephone Discussion, Notification and Scheduling. Fax back the fourth page within 14 calendar days from the date of the letter to indicate election to participate.

At the scheduled date and time that the formal telephone discussion is conducted, the supplier will have the opportunity to provide verbal testimony, submit any missing or critical documentation needed to further support a favorable decision, and receive feedback and/or education on CMS policies and requirements. The formal telephone discussion will be recorded and a copy of the recording will be placed in the administrative case file.

If during the call additional documentation is required to cure claim payment the supplier will be notified in writing and will have 14 days from the formal telephone discussion to submit the additional documentation.

After the Formal Telephone Discussion, C2C will review the verbal testimony and written documentation in the case, apply Medicare policies, and make a decision on the case. The formal telephone discussions offered under this demonstration have a modified timeframe for the issuance of the decision. Instead of the standard 60 days, CMS has extended the time frame to issue a decision under this demonstration to 120 days. If a supplier is dissatisfied with the C2C decision, the supplier will continue to have appeal rights to the Administrative Law Judge.

The 120 days begins from the date that C2C receives the initial appeal. This 120-day timeframe is allotted to account for the scheduling of the formal telephone discussion, time to remit the contact information sheet, hold the discussion, and allow for the 14 days that are given to suppliers to submit additional documentation if needed.

Under the Demonstration, C2C will also conduct reopenings of claims that are similar to those selected as part of the formal telephone discussion. The criteria for reopenings are unfavorable reconsideration decisions dated on, or after, January 1, 2013, and that are from the respective DME MAC Jurisdictions C (CGS) and D (Noridian). Reopenings will include claims previously closed by the QIC, and/or currently pending but not yet scheduled with the ALJ.

C2C will be working closely with the Office of Medicare Hearings and Appeals and the suppliers, as part of the discussion process, to determine if these claims can be reopened by the QIC. They must have a high probability that, upon the submission of the additional requested documentation, the case may warrant a reopening and result in a fully favorable decision.

The Reopening process is as follows:

  • The supplier will be notified in writing of cases included in the reopening process along with the missing or insufficient documentation required to allow payment.
  • Upon receipt of requested documentation, C2C shall confirm the documents support a favorable decision. If a favorable decision cannot be rendered, the supplier will be notified in writing.
  • Notify ALJ of claims that can now be resolved favorably via a C2C reopening, and request cases to be remanded (applicable only to appeals pending at ALJ).
  • Upon receipt of the ALJ remand, as applicable, reopen and render favorable decision.

The Reopening Process Request Form is located on C2C website under the forms link. The form should be completed to request a reopening of a pending ALJ appeal that was denied by the QIC between January 1, 2013 to present. Fax the request to the contact number found under the address portion of the form.

C2C experienced significant delays in responses from suppliers regarding additional documentation request letters, and due to this delay, C2C has changed the time frame to 30 days that the supplier has to remit the requested documentation versus the previous 14 days. C2C sends a letter to the supplier reminding them and outlining the cases that were pending and have a documentation request. C2C is conducting follow-up calls to review the new timeframe and remind suppliers of the cases pending that have documentation requests.

C2C provided an overview of the demonstration for 2017 thus far.  From January to July of this year C2C mailed out over 19 thousand scheduling letters and held approximately 17 thousand formal telephone discussions, which equates to about an 83% participation rate in discussions.   

For the reopening component of the Phone demonstration for far for 2017, C2C have worked with the ALJ on either reopening or having withdrawn from the ALJ approximately 39 thousand claims.

C2C shared lessons learned for for the demonstration thus far. C2C found that it is imperative that the contact information form be returned in a timely manner, and to the correct location.

Education and outreach has to start as soon as possible with the expansion. C2C indicated that they didn't begin education and outreach until March of 2016, which didn't give suppliers enough time to become familiar with the process and aware of what the demonstration was. When the expansion took place C2C learned that they would need to start educating a lot sooner.

C2C found that establishing a point of contact with the suppliers made for a smoother process.

Lifting the five-claim limit per NPI, that was initially on the demonstration, allowed C2C the ability to send more scheduling letters to suppliers who previously exceeded the cap.

For the Reopening process when a business has changed locations sometimes this can cause a delay or prevent the supplier from receiving the correspondence that C2C is sending. C2C asks that if a supplier has changed locations since January of 2013, to let C2C know so that they can ensure Reopening correspondence is going to the correct location.

Lastly the staffing allocations and staffing assignments for some suppliers has been an issue. If there is only one individual assigned to conducting the phone discussions and locating the documents for the reopenings, for suppliers who are submitting large volumes of reconsiderations or have a large number of reopenings that qualify for the demo this can be a daunting task. C2C has been able to meet with executive level administration and communicate these needs to them.

C2C has designated Emily Barnes to assist suppliers with any information related to the demonstration. Her contact information is Emily.Barnes@c2cinc.com. Also, the C2C website that has more information about the Phone Discussion Demonstration at www.c2cinc.comExternal Website. You can find information about the phone discussion demonstration, the reopening process, frequently asked questions, forms as well as our quarterly newsletter. You can also submit your email address to be added to the C2C list serve if you are interested. If suppliers have any feedback regarding the Formal Telephone Discussion email dmepdfeedback@c2cinc.com. This feedback is shared with CMS.

Questions Received During the ACT meeting

Click on a question to expand or Show All / Close All

spacer

26 Century Blvd Ste ST610, Nashville, TN 37214-3685 © CGS Administrators, LLC. All Rights Reserved